Special / Custom Pies

Our legendary custom pies take high quality and creativity to a whole new level.  For our custom treats, we take the finest ingredients and combine them in new and interesting ways to stay on the forefront of the dessert industry.  These pies have won so many blue ribbon awards over the years, that we stopped counting.  You can be assured that when you work with Legendary Baking on a custom or special pie, your customers and guests will enjoy the very best in flavor and creativity.  Note that custom pies do require a minimum order quantity, may or may not be presliced and are not available year round.  Please call us for availability and to discuss options.

Amaretto Silk Pie

Amaretto silk with sliced and toasted almonds folded in creates a unique flavor sensation. Add whipped cream and more sliced almonds to the top you get an irresistible treat.

Base or Finished: 
Base, Finished
Kosher: 
Yes
Sizes: 
9"

Andes Chocolate Mint Pie

The classic flavors of rich chocolate silk and cool mint are blended together in this perennial favorite. Combine it with our famous crust and you have an irresistible taste treat.

Base or Finished: 
Base, Finished
Kosher: 
Yes
Sizes: 
8", 9"

Apple Cranberry Pie

Crisp, sweet apples and tart cranberries come together to create this classic flavor combination.

Baked or Raw: 
Baked, Raw
Kosher: 
Yes
Sizes: 
8", 9"

Black Cherry Pie

A perfect combination of plump, dark cherries and our tender, flaky crust make this classic pie more sweet than tart.

Baked or Raw: 
Baked, Raw
Kosher: 
Yes
Sizes: 
8", 9"

Boston Cream Pie

Some argue that this is a cake and not a pie. We say…who cares when it's this good. Rich vanilla custard and chocolate and vanilla cake layers combine with chocolate to make a beautiful and delicious combination.

Base or Finished: 
Base, Finished
Kosher: 
Yes
Sizes: 
8", 9"

Cherry Vanilla Streusel Pie

A blend of flavors including sweet/tart cherries, rich vanilla and nutty streusel topping. This pie is a delight for the senses.

Baked or Raw: 
Baked, Raw
Kosher: 
Yes
Sizes: 
8", 9"

Chocolate Peanut Sundae Pie

Just like at the sundae shop, a chocolate cookie crust holds peanut butter silk covered in Spanish peanuts, dark fudge sundae sauce and vanilla Bavarian cream. Garnish however you like…maybe a cherry on top...Wow!

Base or Finished: 
Base, Finished
Kosher: 
Yes
Sizes: 
8", 9"

Chocolate Raspberry Truffle Pie

We fill a chocolate cookie crumb crust with layers of rich chocolate ganache and dark chocolate and raspberry silk, then top off with fluffy whipped cream.

Base or Finished: 
Base, Finished
Kosher: 
Yes
Sizes: 
8", 9"

Coffee Cream Pie

Kahlua flavored silk and dark chocolate silk are layered with whipped cream and dusted with cocoa powder. Sure to satisfy any coffee fan's craving.

Base or Finished: 
Base, Finished
Kosher: 
Yes
Sizes: 
8", 9"

Double Chocolate Cherry Pie

The delicate sweetness of white chocolate cream combines with the sweet tartness of cherries to delight your senses. Add to that a hint of milk chocolate from the cookie crust and milk chocolate sprinkles, and you won't be able to resist this sweetheart of a pie.

Base or Finished: 
Base, Finished
Kosher: 
Yes
Sizes: 
8", 9"

French Apple Cream Cheese Pie

We start with a graham cracker crust and add our sweet cream cheese filling and then add a layer of sweet juicy apples. Then we top it all with butter crumb topping and wispy clouds of whipped cream - yummmm.

Base or Finished: 
Base, Finished
Kosher: 
Yes
Sizes: 
8", 9"

Fuzzy Navel

Sweet peaches and juicy oranges combine in this tasty favorite. All that on top of our flaky, fluffy crust, it doesn't get any better than that.
Base or Finished: 
Base, Finished
Kosher: 
Yes
Sizes: 
8", 9"

Irish Cream Pie

Irish cream silk, dark chocolate silk and Irish cream flavored whipped topping make this a decadent treat. Top all of that with chocolate drops and nuts. Consider yourself lucky to get this one.

Base or Finished: 
Base, Finished
Kosher: 
Yes
Sizes: 
8", 9"

Neapolitan Pie

This classic blends dark chocolate silk, vanilla bavarian cream and strawberry silk with a chocolate cookie crust. Cover all that with chocolate ganache and white chocolate stripes - it's like when you were a kid…only better.

Base or Finished: 
Base, Finished
Kosher: 
Yes
Sizes: 
8", 9"

Orange Dream Pie

Reminiscent of the orange cream push pops you enjoyed as a kid, the orange dream pie will bring you back to a simpler time. Everyone deserves to be a kid again.
Base or Finished: 
Base, Finished
Kosher: 
Yes
Sizes: 
8", 9"

Peach Raspberry Cobbler

It's the best of both worlds, you get a flaky pastry crust with crumb streusel added to juicy peaches and red raspberries for the unique flavor of cobbler in a pie.

Baked or Raw: 
Baked, Raw
Kosher: 
Yes
Sizes: 
8", 9"

Peach Raspberry Lattice Pie

Tree-ripened peaches and plump raspberries fill a pastry crust. Then, we top it with a pastry lattice to give it that classic fruit pie look. Enjoy!

Baked or Raw: 
Baked, Raw
Kosher: 
Yes
Sizes: 
8", 9"

Salted Caramel Chocolate Almond

On top of a flaky pastry crust we mix salted caramel and almond pieces.  Top that with a layer of chocolate silk and whipped topping.  Then we drizzle chocolate and carmel and top it all with sliced almonds for a truly decadent sweet and salty treat.

Baked or Raw: 
N/A
Base or Finished: 
Finished
Kosher: 
Yes
Sizes: 
9"
  • Howdy

  • Howdy

  • Howdy

  • Howdy

  • Howdy

  • Howdy

  • Howdy

  • Howdy

  • Howdy

  • Howdy

  • Howdy

  • Howdy

  • Howdy

  • Howdy

  • Howdy

  • Howdy

  • Howdy

  • Howdy

  • Howdy

  • Howdy

  • Howdy

  • Howdy

  • Howdy

  • Howdy

  • Howdy

  • Howdy