Gourmet Pies

The legend was born over forty years ago when the bakers at Legendary Baking began producing premium pies known for their high quality and creativity. Honoring our heritage, we still use the finest ingredients to create the flakiest crusts, richest fillings and most delicious flavors. Legendary pies start with tender, flaky crust and we make ours from scratch every day. You can be assured that when you’re buying from Legendary Baking, your customers and guests will enjoy the very best.

Our pies are standard 9”. Other sizes are available, please contact us.

 

View more

View more

  • Legendary Fruit & Oven Pies

    For our award-winning Fruitabulous™ fruit pies, we source the finest fruit we can find from premier growing regions such as apples from Michigan and New York or blueberries from the Northeast. The fruit used in our pies is picked fresh, and flash frozen to preserve the vibrant flavors. Our Legendary Fruit and Oven Pies are standard 9”. For custom sizes or flavor combinations please contact us.

    Fruitabulous™ Country Apple

    Our award-winning classic represents the best of an American tradition. A pleasing blend of crisp, sweet apples, delicate spices and tender, flaky crust make this pie truly legendary.

  • Fruitabulous™ Cherry

    Plenty of tart, red cherries dance with colossal flavor between two layers of golden, flaky crust.

    Fruitabulous™ Blueberry

    Bursting with plump, juicy blueberries, this pie is an all-time favorite.

  • Fruitabulous™ Strawberry Rhubarb

    Sweet strawberries and tender, ripe rhubarb come together to create and exciting taste sensation.

    Fruitabulous™ Triple Berry

    Plump blueberries, tart raspberries and luscious boysenberries in our award-winning, flaky crust make this pie and unbeatable flavor combination.

  • Fruitabulous™ Peach

    Our peach pie is loaded with sliced, juicy, ripe peaches in a flaky crust.

    Apple Lattice

    A lattice top version of our award winning apple pie, featuring crisp, sweet apples, delicate spices and our legendary flaky crust.

  • French Apple

    Our traditional apple filling is crowned with a rich butter crumb topping, then slowly baked to perfection.

    Apple Streusel

    An irresistible blend of crisp, sweet apples and delicate spices, topped with a rich, brown sugar crumb topping, then baked to perfection.

  • Pumpkin

    Our smooth, creamy pumpkin filling is made with only the finest ingredients and carefully spiced with cinnamon, nutmeg and ginger.

    Pecan

    Plenty of buttery pecans top our caramel filling, giving this Southern classic a rich, nutty flavor.

  • Black Cherry

    A perfect combination of plump, dark cherries and our tender, flaky crust make this classic pie more sweet than tart.

  • Elite Cream Pies

    Our Elite Cream Pies are a cut above – when only the finest ingredients and innovative flavor combinations will do! What makes these pies truly legendary are the layers of rich flavors and textures using premium ingredients. Our Elite Cream Pies are standard 9”. For custom sizes or flavor combinations please contact us.

    French Silk

    One of our most popular and best-selling pies, this is truly a chocolate lover’s dream. Our tender, flaky crust is filled with velvety smooth chocolate silk and topped with fluffy whipped topping and milk chocolate shavings.

  • Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup

    Irresistible layers of chocolate ganache and peanut butter silk sit atop a chopped peanut graham cracker crust and generously topped with whipped topping.

    Caramel Pecan Silk Supreme

    Layers of rich caramel with pecans, vanilla supreme and French Silk are nestled under whipped topping and drizzled with dark chocolate, caramel and pecans.

  • Oreo® Cookie

    Chocolate cookie crust filling with Oreo® cookie silk, a layer of chocolate cookie crumb, finished with whipped topping.

    Pumpkin Cream

    Perfectly spiced pumpkin filling topped with a sumptuous layer of whipped topping and dusted with nutmeg.

  • Lemon Supreme

    Silky supreme cream cheese is covered with tangy lemon filling and topped with a border of whipped topping.

    Peach Supreme

    Baked pastry crust filled with our award-winning vanilla supreme, topped with tree-ripened peaches and finished with a border of whipped topping.

  • Triple Berry Supreme

    Baked pastry shell with a beautiful pinkish triple berry supreme. Topped with our famous triple berry filling, decorated with whipped topping.

    Cherry Supreme

    Baked pastry crust filled with our award-winning vanilla supreme, topped with tart, juicy cherry filling and finished with a border of whipped topping.

  • Supreme Kits

    Our award-winning supreme base and your fresh fruit come together to deliver an unbeatable taste sensation. Our Supreme Kits include a baked pastry crust with our vanilla supreme filling and a package of fruit glaze. Add the seasonal berries of your choice to create your own Supreme pie.

  • Gourmet Cream Pies

    Our Gourmet Cream Pies combine premium ingredients with time-honored pie making tradition to create rich, delicious flavors. We make our cream pies to your specifications, using the finest ingredients. Whether refrigerated or shelf stable, our classic, Gourmet Cream Pies will delight your guests and keep them coming back for more! Our Gourmet Cream Pies are standard 9”. For custom sizes or flavor combinations please contact us.

    Key Lime

    Creamy, tangy Key lime filling sits atop our graham cracker crust to create this classic tropical taste sensation.

  • Coconut Cream

    Creamy coconut filling envelopes delicately shredded coconut under a blanket of whipped topping and toasted coconut.

    Banana Cream

    Sumptuous banana filling sits atop our flaky, golden crust topped with whipped topping and sliced almonds.

  • Chocolate Cream

    This captivating classic features our rich milk chocolate filling topped with whipped topping and sprinkled with chocolate chips.

    Chocolate Top Chocolate Cream

    Our decadent milk chocolate filling is topped with chocolate whipped topping and sprinkled with chocolate shavings.

  • Heavenly Meringues

    Our Heavenly Meringues combine delicious flavors like lemon, coconut, chocolate and key lime with delicate, golden baked meringue. Whether you’re looking for the precision of a machine-deposited meringue or the more homemade look of a hand-peaked meringue, Legendary Baking can create the perfect meringue pie for your guests. Our Heavenly Meringues are standard 9”. For custom sizes or flavor combinations please contact us.

    Lemon
    Meringue

    Golden baked meringue floats atop our tangy lemon filling, creating a delectable sweet - tart combination.

  • Coconut Meringue

    Creamy coconut filling loaded with shredded coconut and topped with delicate meringue.

    Chocolate Meringue

    Our rich, decadent chocolate filling is topped with a layer of delicate meringue.

  • Key Lime Meringue

    Sweet, tart and creamy Key lime filling is topped with a layer of golden baked meringue.

  • Custom Creations

    We work with our customers to create signature pies that showcase the high quality and creativity we’re known for at Legendary Baking. There is no limit to our creativity when it comes to developing truly unique pies you can proudly serve your customers with the confidence that they’re getting something legendary. Examples of some of our premium, custom creations include:

    Hawaiian Strawberry

    A taste of paradise with a tender, flaky crust and decadent supreme filling with pineapple, coconut and crunchy pecans. Topped with sweet, glazed strawberries, whipped topping, coconut sprinkles, chopped pecans and pineapple.

  • Mint Brownie Blast

    Our flaky crust with a brownie bottom, cool mint silk with chocolate brownie pieces and topped with whipped topping.

    Birthday Cake

    Layers of French Silk, cake and cake batter Bavarian cream create this unique pie that’s perfect for any celebration.